{ "provenance": "Recorded from bridge.astra_runtime using deterministic sample providers. No live Astra call.", "question": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?", "steering": "Focus only on the Missouri pilot. Retire the national checklist and verify local acceptance requirements.", "scoped": { "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "event": "plan", "details": { "question": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?" } }, { "sequence": 2, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": null, "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [ "astra_investigator", "claim_mapper", "evidence_checker", "evidence_scout", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 3, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 4, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 5, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 6, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 7, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 8, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 9, "event": "graph_created", "details": { "graph": { "version": 1, "nodes": [ { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } ], "active_nodes": 5, "total_nodes": 5, "blocked_roles": [], "mutations": [ { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } } ] } } }, { "sequence": 10, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 11, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 12, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout" } }, { "sequence": 13, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout" } }, { "sequence": 14, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 15, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n001", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" } ] } }, { "sequence": 16, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 17, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 18, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 19, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n004", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/national-checklist", "title": "National checklist \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The national checklist marks all regions ready for launch.", "id": "source-2" } ] } }, { "sequence": 20, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 21, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 22, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 23, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 24, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 25, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 26, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 27, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 28, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 29, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 30, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 31, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 32, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 33, "event": "verification", "details": { "node_id": "n003", "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ] } }, { "sequence": 34, "event": "claim", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 35, "event": "conflict", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 36, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 37, "event": "reasoning_escalation", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 38, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 39, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [ "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 40, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 41, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 42, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 43, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 44, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 45, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 46, "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "details": { "instruction": "Focus only on the Missouri pilot. Retire the national checklist and verify local acceptance requirements.", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [ "n012", "n013", "n014", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021" ], "preserved": [ "n001" ], "retired": [ "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005", "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ] } }, { "sequence": 47, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 48, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n013", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012", "n015" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 49, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n014", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n013" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 50, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n015", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 51, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n016", "role": "challenger", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 52, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 53, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n018", "role": "arbiter", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n013", "n014", "n016", "n017", "n021" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 54, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n019", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 55, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n020", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 56, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n021", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n019", "n020", "n017", "n016" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 57, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 58, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 59, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 60, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 61, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 62, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 63, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 64, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 65, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 66, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 67, "event": "node_retired", "details": { "node": { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 68, "event": "graph_steered", "details": { "mutation": { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n012", "n013", "n014", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021" ], "retired": [ "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005", "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "preserved": [ "n001" ], "details": { "instruction": "Focus only on the Missouri pilot. Retire the national checklist and verify local acceptance requirements.", "reasoning": "high" } } } }, { "sequence": 69, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 70, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 71, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 72, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 73, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout" } }, { "sequence": 74, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 75, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n012", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-acceptance", "title": "Missouri acceptance results \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ] } }, { "sequence": 76, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 77, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 78, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 79, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n015", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 80, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n015", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 81, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 82, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 83, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n013", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012", "n015" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 84, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n013", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012", "n015" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 85, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 86, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 87, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n014", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n013" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 88, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n014", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n013" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 89, "event": "verification", "details": { "node_id": "n014", "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ] } }, { "sequence": 90, "event": "claim", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 91, "event": "conflict", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 92, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 93, "event": "reasoning_escalation", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 94, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 95, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 96, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n016", "role": "challenger", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 97, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 98, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n019", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 99, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n020", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 100, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout" } }, { "sequence": 101, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n016", "role": "challenger", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 102, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 103, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 104, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 105, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n017", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-acceptance", "title": "Missouri acceptance results \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ] } }, { "sequence": 106, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 107, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 108, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n019", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 109, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 110, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 111, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n020", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 112, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 113, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 114, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n021", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n019", "n020", "n017", "n016" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 115, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n021", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n019", "n020", "n017", "n016" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 116, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 117, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 118, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n018", "role": "arbiter", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n013", "n014", "n016", "n017", "n021" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 119, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n018", "role": "arbiter", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n013", "n014", "n016", "n017", "n021" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 120, "event": "arbitration", "details": { "node_id": "n018" } }, { "sequence": 121, "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [ "n022" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 122, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n022", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n018" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 123, "event": "graph_steered", "details": { "mutation": { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n022" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high" } } } }, { "sequence": 124, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 125, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 126, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n022", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n018" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 127, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n022", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n018" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "competing_hypotheses", "source_quality", "source_quality_reason" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 128, "event": "verification", "details": { "node_id": "n022", "claims": [ { "claim": "The Missouri pilot passed its human-handoff and audit-logging acceptance tests.", "status": "SUPPORTED", "evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ], "excerpts": { "source-2": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot." }, "grounded_evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ] } ] } }, { "sequence": 129, "event": "claim", "details": { "claim": "The Missouri pilot passed its human-handoff and audit-logging acceptance tests.", "status": "SUPPORTED", "evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ], "excerpts": { "source-2": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot." }, "grounded_evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ] } }, { "sequence": 130, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EVIDENCE_CONVERGED" ], "may_collapse": true } } }, { "sequence": 131, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EVIDENCE_CONVERGED" ], "may_collapse": true } } }, { "sequence": 132, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 133, "event": "GRAPH_COLLAPSED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "spawned": [], "preserved": [ "n012", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021", "n022" ], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 134, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 135, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n015", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 136, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n016", "role": "challenger", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 137, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 138, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n018", "role": "arbiter", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n013", "n014", "n016", "n017", "n021" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 139, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n019", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 140, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n020", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 141, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n021", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n019", "n020", "n017", "n016" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 142, "event": "node_preserved", "details": { "node": { "id": "n022", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n018" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "competing_hypotheses", "source_quality", "source_quality_reason" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 143, "event": "graph_collapsed", "details": { "mutation": { "event": "GRAPH_COLLAPSED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [ "n012", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021", "n022" ], "details": { "mode": "grounded" } } } }, { "sequence": 144, "event": "answer", "details": { "response": { "question": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?", "answer": "Proceed with a limited Missouri pilot. Human handoff and audit logging passed the scoped acceptance tests. Do not extend this conclusion to a national rollout.", "draft": "A limited Missouri pilot can proceed after the local acceptance results are checked.", "evidence": { "query": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-acceptance", "title": "Missouri acceptance results \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ] }, "verification": { "source_quality": 0.9, "source_quality_reason": "Explicitly scoped sample acceptance record", "competing_hypotheses": 1, "claims": [ { "claim": "The Missouri pilot passed its human-handoff and audit-logging acceptance tests.", "status": "SUPPORTED", "evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ], "excerpts": { "source-2": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot." } } ] }, "intelligence_state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EVIDENCE_CONVERGED" ], "may_collapse": true }, "trace": { "model": "deterministic-demo-fixture (no live model call)", "topology": "grounded", "graph_nodes_created": 22, "graph_nodes_retired": 10, "graph_nodes_preserved": 10, "tools_used": 3, "revisions": 1, "total_latency_ms": 7, "stop_reason": "settled", "confidence_method": "source_linked_claim_support_fraction; not calibrated probability" }, "execution_graph": { "version": 1, "nodes": [ { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "retired", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n012", "role": "missouri_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n013", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012", "n015" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n014", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n013" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n015", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n012" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n016", "role": "challenger", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n017", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n018", "role": "arbiter", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n013", "n014", "n016", "n017", "n021" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n019", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n020", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n014" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n021", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n019", "n020", "n017", "n016" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n022", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "preserved", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n018" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "competing_hypotheses", "source_quality", "source_quality_reason" ], "completed": true } } ], "active_nodes": 12, "total_nodes": 22, "blocked_roles": [ "parallel_scout" ], "mutations": [ { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n012", "n013", "n014", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021" ], "retired": [ "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005", "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "preserved": [ "n001" ], "details": { "instruction": "Focus only on the Missouri pilot. Retire the national checklist and verify local acceptance requirements.", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n022" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_COLLAPSED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [ "n012", "n015", "n016", "n017", "n018", "n019", "n020", "n021", "n022" ], "details": { "mode": "grounded" } } ] }, "evidence_graph": { "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-acceptance", "title": "Missouri acceptance results \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ], "claims": [ { "claim": "The Missouri pilot passed its human-handoff and audit-logging acceptance tests.", "status": "SUPPORTED", "evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ], "excerpts": { "source-2": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot." }, "grounded_evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ] } ] }, "confidence": 1.0, "evidence_state": "verified", "claims": [ { "claim": "The Missouri pilot passed its human-handoff and audit-logging acceptance tests.", "status": "SUPPORTED", "evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ], "excerpts": { "source-2": "Missouri acceptance tests confirm human handoff and audit logging passed. Approval is limited to the Missouri pilot." }, "grounded_evidence_ids": [ "source-2" ] } ], "contradictions": [], "uncertainties": [], "reasoning_profile": { "initial_effort": "high", "peak_effort": "xhigh", "reason": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EVIDENCE_CONVERGED" ] } } } } ], "answer": "Proceed with a limited Missouri pilot. Human handoff and audit logging passed the scoped acceptance tests. Do not extend this conclusion to a national rollout.", "evidence_state": "verified" }, "unscoped": { "events": [ { "sequence": 1, "event": "plan", "details": { "question": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?" } }, { "sequence": 2, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": null, "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [ "astra_investigator", "claim_mapper", "evidence_checker", "evidence_scout", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 3, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 4, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 5, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 6, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 7, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 8, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 9, "event": "graph_created", "details": { "graph": { "version": 1, "nodes": [ { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} }, { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } ], "active_nodes": 5, "total_nodes": 5, "blocked_roles": [], "mutations": [ { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } } ] } } }, { "sequence": 10, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 11, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 12, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout" } }, { "sequence": 13, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout" } }, { "sequence": 14, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 15, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n001", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" } ] } }, { "sequence": 16, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "investigative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 17, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 18, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 19, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n004", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/national-checklist", "title": "National checklist \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The national checklist marks all regions ready for launch.", "id": "source-2" } ] } }, { "sequence": 20, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 21, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "investigative", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 22, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 23, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 24, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 25, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 26, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 27, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 28, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 29, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "grounded", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 30, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 31, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 32, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 33, "event": "verification", "details": { "node_id": "n003", "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ] } }, { "sequence": 34, "event": "claim", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 35, "event": "conflict", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 36, "event": "TOPOLOGY_CHANGED", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 37, "event": "reasoning_escalation", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 38, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "grounded", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [ "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "arbiter", "challenger", "claim_mapper", "counter_evidence_scout", "hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge", "parallel_scout" ], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 39, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [ "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 40, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 41, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 42, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 43, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 44, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 45, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 46, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 47, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 48, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 49, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 50, "event": "search", "details": { "node_id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout" } }, { "sequence": 51, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 52, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 53, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 54, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 55, "event": "evidence", "details": { "node_id": "n007", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/national-checklist", "title": "National checklist \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The national checklist marks all regions ready for launch.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ] } }, { "sequence": 56, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 57, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 58, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 59, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 60, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 61, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 62, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 63, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 64, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 65, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 66, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 67, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 68, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 69, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 70, "event": "arbitration", "details": { "node_id": "n008" } }, { "sequence": 71, "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high", "spawned": [ "n012" ], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 72, "event": "node_spawned", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "pending", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n008" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 73, "event": "graph_steered", "details": { "mutation": { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n012" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high" } } } }, { "sequence": 74, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 75, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 76, "event": "node_started", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "running", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n008" ], "metadata": {} } } }, { "sequence": 77, "event": "node_completed", "details": { "node": { "id": "n012", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n008" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } } }, { "sequence": 78, "event": "verification", "details": { "node_id": "n012", "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ] } }, { "sequence": 79, "event": "claim", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 80, "event": "conflict", "details": { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } }, { "sequence": 81, "event": "orchestration_state", "details": { "from_mode": "deliberative", "to_mode": "deliberative", "spawned_agents": [], "state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false } } }, { "sequence": 82, "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "spawned": [], "preserved": [], "retired": [] } }, { "sequence": 83, "event": "answer", "details": { "response": { "question": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?", "answer": "Do not authorize the all-region launch yet. The national checklist does not resolve Missouri\u2019s human-handoff and audit-logging requirements.", "draft": "The national checklist suggests every region is ready. The regional acceptance requirements still need checking.", "evidence": { "query": "Should we launch our AI support assistant across all regions on Monday?", "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/national-checklist", "title": "National checklist \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The national checklist marks all regions ready for launch.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ] }, "verification": { "source_quality": 0.6, "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate." } ] }, "intelligence_state": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh", "agents": [ "evidence_scout", "astra_investigator", "evidence_checker", "parallel_scout", "claim_mapper", "challenger", "counter_evidence_scout", "arbiter", "hypothesis_builder", "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "hypothesis_judge" ], "rationale_codes": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ], "may_collapse": false }, "trace": { "model": "deterministic-demo-fixture (no live model call)", "topology": "deliberative", "graph_nodes_created": 12, "graph_nodes_retired": 0, "graph_nodes_preserved": 0, "tools_used": 3, "revisions": 1, "total_latency_ms": 3, "stop_reason": "unresolved", "confidence_method": "source_linked_claim_support_fraction; not calibrated probability" }, "execution_graph": { "version": 1, "nodes": [ { "id": "n001", "role": "evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n002", "role": "astra_investigator", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004", "n005" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n003", "role": "evidence_checker", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n002" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n004", "role": "parallel_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n005", "role": "claim_mapper", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "medium", "depends_on": [ "n001", "n004" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n006", "role": "challenger", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n007", "role": "counter_evidence_scout", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "low", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "sources" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n008", "role": "arbiter", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n002", "n003", "n006", "n007", "n011" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n009", "role": "hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n010", "role": "alternative_hypothesis_builder", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n003" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n011", "role": "hypothesis_judge", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "xhigh", "depends_on": [ "n009", "n010", "n007", "n006" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "text" ], "completed": true } }, { "id": "n012", "role": "final_verifier", "status": "complete", "reasoning_effort": "high", "depends_on": [ "n008" ], "metadata": { "result_keys": [ "claims", "source_quality" ], "completed": true } } ], "active_nodes": 12, "total_nodes": 12, "blocked_roles": [], "mutations": [ { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n001", "n002", "n003", "n004", "n005" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "investigative", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "grounded", "reasoning": "medium" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [ "n006", "n007", "n008", "n009", "n010", "n011" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_STEERED", "spawned": [ "n012" ], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "instruction": "", "reasoning": "high" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } }, { "event": "GRAPH_MATERIALIZED", "spawned": [], "retired": [], "preserved": [], "details": { "mode": "deliberative", "reasoning": "xhigh" } } ] }, "evidence_graph": { "sources": [ { "url": "https://example.org/demo/technical-readiness", "title": "Technical readiness \u00b7 sample document", "content": "Load tests passed at expected pilot volume.", "id": "source-1" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/national-checklist", "title": "National checklist \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The national checklist marks all regions ready for launch.", "id": "source-2" }, { "url": "https://example.org/demo/missouri-contract", "title": "Missouri pilot contract \u00b7 sample document", "content": "The Missouri pilot requires working human handoff and verified audit logging. These acceptance checks remain unresolved in the national checklist.", "id": "source-3" } ], "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ] }, "confidence": 0.0, "evidence_state": "unverified", "claims": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ], "contradictions": [ { "claim": "All regions are ready for launch.", "status": "CONFLICTED", "evidence_ids": [], "excerpts": {}, "reason": "National readiness does not resolve the Missouri acceptance gate.", "grounded_evidence_ids": [] } ], "uncertainties": [ "All regions are ready for launch.", "Conclusion has not passed all verification gates." ], "reasoning_profile": { "initial_effort": "high", "peak_effort": "xhigh", "reason": [ "EXTERNAL_EVIDENCE_REQUIRED", "EXPAND_INVESTIGATION", "EVIDENCE_CONFLICT", "COMPETING_HYPOTHESES" ] } } } } ], "answer": "Do not authorize the all-region launch yet. The national checklist does not resolve Missouri\u2019s human-handoff and audit-logging requirements.", "evidence_state": "unverified" }, "shared_event_count": 45 }